When was the last time you saw a character in a tv or book whose entire life revolves around their heterosexuality?
Never? Me too. Admittedly, heterosexual people have not gone through the horrible atrocities the LGBTQ community has dealt with over the course of history. Straight people do not have to deal with the potential of being kicked out of their homes once they come out. Obviously, the LGBTQ community does need novels about coming out.
But why are the vast majority of LGBTQ YA books only about the beginning of a queer person’s identity? These books tend to revolve exclusively around the protagonist’s coming out struggle. In certain TV shows and books – like Glee’s Kurt for instance – it seems that the main character’s only reason for existence in this world is to be gay, and they have no other wants, motivations or desires.
Why aren’t there more books with gay protagonists who have bigger worries than their sexuality – like saving the world – on their mind? Bisexual characters who have to deal with the biases in their community? Transpeople who are total badasses and polyamorous teens coming into their own? The BTQ in LGBTQ needs to be better represented if LGBTQ lit is going to evolve in the way that will get consumers – queer and straight alike – reading.
What I want most to see as a reader who loves stories with narratives our heteronormative society rarely sees, is LGBTQ literature evolve from a genre of fiction into a secondary thought on the dust jacket. Because just as YA isn’t really a genre so much as a label for the protagonist of the story, LGBTQ lit is much the same thing. It’s time for the mainstream industry to start acting like it.
My desperate hunger for these kind of YA novels is not being completely ignored. Authors like David Levithan are known for writing books about characters who deal with love and politics, and happen to be gay. Books like Hex Hall and The Mortal Instruments Series too, have characters whose sexuality is less important than their personality.
I love LGBTQ fiction. It has provided me with the kind of tender romances that make me believe love is possible. But if YA is ever going to truly satisfy me and plenty of others as readers, it’s going to have to diversify in all directions, and give YA readers the fresh narratives they deserve.
Are there any particular LGBTQ stories you’ve been itching to see in YA fiction? I’d love to hear about them.
Emma Allison blogs at http://bookingthrough365.blogspot.com/
[…] And the church said AMEN!!!! […]
I want to see a girl to move to a small town and fall in love with a beautiful mysterious girl who turns out to be a vampire.
I want to see a guy shed his skin and howl at the moon with another guy.
I want to see a retelling of The Little Mermaid with the titular character being trans rather than cis.
I want to see the angel a person falls in love with being genderqueer.
I want the next love triangle that involves fans splitting into teams to be about “Team Girl” vs “Team Boy”.
I want GLBTQ teens to save the world, their best friend, the president or anyone else.
I just want the same stories as we see with straight couples – the fantasy, the paranormal, the sci fi, the historical and more – only with GLBTQ characters.
I love Catherine’s ideas.
I really think publishing is moving away from the strictly-coming-out story. There are still books coming out where that’s the main focus, whether it’s self-discovery or self-acceptance or acceptance within the community, but I have noticed a real shift in the past couple of years. For example, the past several books I’ve read with queer female characters — Pink, She Loves You, She Loves You Not, Very LeFreak, Wildthorn — acknowledge and incorporate that identity in the story but don’t revolve around it.
Where I’m noticing the more coming-out-focused books right now is in the area of trans characters. And since there was basically nothing but Luna until a couple of years ago, that’s largely a positive thing, I think. I think it will the same pattern as gay and lesbian books — a movement from coming-out stories to stories in which trans identity is but a facet of a character and not the focus of the entire story. But first things first; there’s some Trans 101 at work here, and that’s not all bad.
In other words, I think it’s pretty clear that authors and publishers ARE on top of this issue and that the new trend IS to seek more diversity and to pursue stories where minority sexual and gender identities are normalized.
I personally think the greatest deficiency right now is queer characters of ethnicities other than European-American. I think this is being worked on — I Am J and Hidden are two recent books with non-white main characters that come to mind, and I can think of a handful of other books with queer Asian and Hispanic characters. But I have to go all the way back to The Necessary Hunger to name a black lesbian character… I hope I’m just forgetful, but regardless, that’s pretty sad.
I totally agree! My upcoming book (first in a series) is about twin brothers – one gay, one straight – and although the gay twin’s sexuality is important to the book, so is the mystery, adventure and fun.
Coming out books are important, but young readers deserve more.
Sam Cameron
fisherkey.wordpress.com
I completely agree with you and always have! At least now there are some books where coming out isn’t the issue, that’s all there was when I was a teen. But on the other hand that’s what made me get into writing because I wasn’t seeing what I wanted to read on the shelves.
I just released my GayYa(LesbianYa?) called “Morning Rising” on the Kindle and the Nook. It is exactly what I wanted when I was a teen, something about a girl who finds herself in a strange world and has to find and save the girl she is destined to be with!
Thank you so much for all the lovely comments!
Catherine: Those concepts are exceptional. I especially love the Little Mermaid idea. Gorgeous.
Lisa: That’s a great point, and I would LOVE to see LGBT characters of different cultures and ethnicity. There is so many great new narratives that we’re going to see in the coming years from authors. I’m very excited.
Sam: That sounds wonderful. EVERY reader deserves a story they can relate to and enjoy. Especially if they can better understand sexuality and simultaneously have a fun time exploring the plot.
Samantha: When I read your little paragraph about Morning Rising, I squeed. That is what I’m talking about! More plot driven stories with queer characters make my day.
Emma: I sent a review request to your website, I’d be glad to send you an ebook for you to review!
So much in agreement. It’s not that coming-out stories aren’t important; it’s that I want to see awesome space adventures and fantasy quests with QUILTBAG protagonists. I’m actually working on a YA fantasy adventure with a genderqueer protagonist, and I had something else on the go about a bunch of gender studies students during the zombie apocalypse… it’s nice to know some people share my appetite for awesome stories with queer protagonists!
[…] This post has been one of my favorites. […]